These are all my Classic mould American Girl dolls, in alphabetical / numerical order.

Reminder:
1. All dolls were purchased used from eBay unless otherwise indicated.
2. VDFC = very dilute fabric conditioner (1% in tap water) = my improvised braid spray.
3. Photo conditions vary so don’t compare skin tones.

Caroline
I already had many of the nineteenth century dolls when I saw this listing and I wasn’t really looking for her but she was a good price and I wanted to complete the set. She came with her meet outfit (including shoes) but no accessories, and her hair was a little bit dry. She’s had the VDFC treatment and I’m looking forward to dressing her in period costume.

Emily 1
A nice doll, hair in good condition. She came in the Spooky Fun Halloween costume without the skirt, but I can make one very easily if I want to sell the outfit. The shorter hair is a little limiting but I’m sure I can work with it.

Emily 2
I actually thought she was a Felicity because the listing only had one photo which was very yellow and didn’t show the hair length, and she was described simply as “American Girl Doll”. Still, she’s in good condition. Probably for sale later on.

Felicity 1 BF
Bought along with Elizabeth 1, and in very good condition. Her body tag says ©2013 so she must have been one of the last batch made before her first retirement. [Edit: I was checking a few things and realised that Felicity was actually retired in 2011, so this must be another frankendoll.  Oh well.]  When I measured her I found that she has both the smallest waist and widest hips of all my AG dolls (25 and 32 cm respectively), so I’m in a little dilemma — do I work with her as she is, or do I enhance her proportions by making a couple of darts in her waist? Victorian fashions want to know.

Felicity 2 PC
I wanted a Pleasant Company Felicity to compare her with the Mattel version, and this one came with the original rose garden gown. Her neck says “Pleasant Company” and she has a short “Made in China” tag, so probably from the mid-90s. She’s a little chunkier than the Mattel version — the chest is the same size, but the waist is larger and the hips narrower (29 and 30 cm respectively). The seller was honest about her condition — very loose joints and frizzy hair — but I figured I could remedy that myself. Unfortunately her wig really is very poor — there’s not much hair left and the mesh is very baggy and is torn in a couple of places. On the other hand, I get to practise re-stringing limbs and I can replace the wig with one of a better quality. Like most PC dolls she could also do with a face-paint touch-up.

Isabelle
I bought this doll because she came with the “Tis the Season” outfit that I figured I could sell to offset some of the cost. She’s in great condition but there’s no emotional connection, and now that I have so many other AG dolls I may well sell her too.

Kailey
Mis-identified as Julie in the listing, which probably contributed to the lack of interest from other buyers This was another overnight “leave it to fate” auction, and I was surprised that I won with the minimum bid. She is in very good condition, with glossy hair and no markings. The plaits are both irritating and useless so I’ll take them out and straighten the hair and then I’ll make an attempt at putting her hair up in 18th century style or possibly a 1960s bouffant updo.

Kirsten
She has a brown body and her tag says “Made in Germany” so she’s from the early 1990s — definitely the oldest AG doll I have. Almost all her face paint has gone and her hair has been trimmed, but it still reaches to her chest. The fringe is very thick and wide, consistent with the era, but it looks rather odd now. Hair is dry but in good condition considering her age. I’d like to try various northern European outfits on her, including Swedish or Norwegian national dress.

Kit
I got her because she was pretty cheap (there are many, many Kits on eBay), but I’m fairly lukewarm about her. The short hair is difficult to style properly and she is limited to 20th century outfits. On the other hand, this is the hairstyle I had for much of my own childhood so there is a bit of nostalgia when I look at her. I don’t think ball dresses are in her future but she may get some child-appropriate outfits. Or maybe 1920s … it’s not quite a 20s bob but I might be able to work with it. I wonder if anyone makes doll-size cloche hats?

Lindsey
I don’t like the official AG photo of her and she wasn’t on my mental list of dolls to get, but then I found an eBay sale where she looked great. I was even more pleased with her once I got to see her in person. She has the misprinted “American Gril” tag. Her wig is in excellent condition and with a little effort I can get all her curls to point inwards. She’s going to be great for mid-20th century clothing (Dior New Look and Chanel suits in particular).

Maryellen 1
The very last historical doll I needed (prior to Courtney’s release). She was bought with Elizabeth 2 in an overnight auction — I put my bid in and went to bed, trusting to fate, and was pleasantly surprised the next morning to find I had won. I don’t know why I was the only bidder, since she’s in good condition, but I’m not complaining! She is so very much a 1950s doll that I’m sure I’ll make a couple of frou-frou dresses for her.

Maryellen 2
Like Blaire, technically this isn’t my doll. I bought her directly from AG for my cousin Jo to use as a model for crochet clothing, but when we all move in together she will return to her sisters. Suzy sent me this photo and it’s the only one I have.

Molly
Her head is marked Pleasant Company and she has no body tag, so probably another 1990s doll. I actually bought her because she came with several pairs of earrings that I could use in other dolls (as well as her satchel, which I may sell). Her hair was extremely dry when I got her — I found a pure water spray did nothing, but VDFC made it manageable (she was the first doll I used VDFC on). The fringe limits her to 20th century styles and, most likely, child-appropriate outfits. She doesn’t have her glasses but I’ll try to get a pair for her.

Ruthie
This was a doll I wanted because of her unique hair colour — very dark brown with burgundy/purple tints. She’s not a common listing but I was lucky enough to find one by accident, in very good condition, at a reasonable price with low postage. I might have got her for USD 15 less but the auction expired at 5 am (my time) and there were 5 listed watchers, so I paid the “Buy It Now” price. The hair is glossy and curly and a truly beautiful colour, so I’m very happy to have her in my collection.

Saige
Another doll I wasn’t looking for, but she was local (from Victoria) and relatively cheap. Her hair is in good condition and she came in her meet outfit. Since she has much the same colouring as Felicity I can see myself doing them up as twins. Even though I don’t care for freckles I think I’ll leave them be on Saige so that she doesn’t get mixed up with Felicity.

Samantha 1 PC
You can’t have an AG collection without Samantha, so I bought this one. She is very chubby (second largest overall) and has no body tag, so she’s probably from the 1990s. Her hair was dry and a little frizzy but responded to VDFC treatment, and she came in an interesting home-made dress that is way too large for her but with a little alteration will fit my 22″ doll Julie. For an old doll she’s in pretty good condition but I may re-do her face paint, which has almost completely worn away.

Samantha 2 BF
Of all the dolls that have both PC and Mattel versions, I think Samantha has the most significant face change. The 2014 version is so much more delicate in comparison with the original PC mould that they could almost be considered different dolls (I’ll do a separate post on mould comparisons later on). This one came in the Be Forever meet dress but with different shoes. Hair was in very good condition and only needed a light comb through.

#05
The photograph on this listing was so dark I honestly thought I was buying a Samantha and was quite surprised when I unwrapped her. Medium skin, red hair and brown eyes make for a very unusual look — I didn’t know that red hair and brown eyes could co-exist but I’ve since learned that it is found in Eastern Europe (I thought Scottish actress Karen Gillan might have brown eyes too, but they are officially described as hazel). I’m not sure how to dress her yet but I’m sure that inspiration will strike.

#12
She could be a Gwen, but is much more likely to be #12 (no body tag). She’s in very good condition for an older doll. I may do an eye swap as I need a pair of brown eyes for Kanani 2 and this doll would be fine with hazel.

#15
I really wasn’t supposed to get this doll. It was right at the end of my early 2020 eBay marathon — I’d bought Melody, I’d bought Nellie, and I was just waiting on a Cecile auction as my final eBay purchase (for then) when I ran my AG search one more time and found this listing. I was quite surprised to see it — I’d been monitoring eBay fairly constantly for almost six months and she was the first #15 I’d seen (and I haven’t seen one since). I ended up staying up until 5 am to win the auction at the last minute, which I don’t normally do, but in between putting my bid in and actually preparing to switch off the laptop there were two more bids so I knew I wasn’t going to win it if I wasn’t awake. She has textured hair which is very dry and brittle, like Addy’s, and wasn’t much helped by VDFC so she’s heading for a deep conditioning treatment and then probably Polynesian or South American outfits.

#17
A local purchase from a woman in Queensland. Although a little expensive for a used doll ($125 + postage) she is in beautiful condition and is destined for Anne Shirley cosplay (and yes, I know Anne has green eyes but I’ve never seen an #08 for sale) or possibly Anna from Frozen.

#21
Her hair was wild when I got her but the usual VDFC treatment has tamed it. I like the caramel/strawberry blonde colour of the hair, but short hair is very limiting, so again probably 20th century styles only, or outfits that include a head covering.

#22 A
This one was the second doll I purchased (after Marie-Grace 1) and at the time I honestly thought it would be my only AG reference doll (Oh, how naïve I was!). She was very cheap and was sold “for parts or repair” but is in relatively good shape for all that. The nail polish on her fingers came off easily, and so did most of the other marks. She has some black marking around her eye sockets that is proving difficult to treat without getting solvent on the eyes so I may have to take them out and use acetone on the sockets. Given her typical northern European colouring, I want to dress her in a dirndl along with #25 for “Snow White and Rose Red” cosplay, or maybe Alice.

#22 B
Another Queensland purchase, and the only one I actually regret — she and all the clothes she came with are incredibly musty (I think she must have been stored in an uninsulated garage for a few years). I discarded all the body stuffing immediately, but three weeks on the balcony (before the bushfires) and several months in baking soda didn’t do much to combat the smell in the body and limbs. The head was surrounded by lavender bags, also with limited success. The clothes were treated with alternating Vanish (Oxyclean) and vinegar, which completely ruined the metal parts. Oh well. I’m now contemplating using her for experiments in solvents and pigments, and also using her feet as lasts for making shoes.

#23
This is a fairly nondescript doll — classic mould, blue eyes, mid-brown hair. She’s in good condition but I’m having trouble getting any emotional attachment to her so she’s another that may get sold later on.  [Edit: She’s also the most columnar doll, her measurements being 27-28-28 (10 5/8 – 11 – 11) so 1920s dresses will suit her admirably. She stays.]

#25
This was the next doll I bought after #22A because I love her colouring – with her dark hair and eyes she is the perfect foil as Rose Red for #22’s Snow White. She would also do well for Diana Barry, paired with #17 as Anne Shirley. She was in very good condition for the price and didn’t need much in the way of cleaning up.

#27
Although very similar to #22, this one has much darker blue eyes and longer blonde hair. She came in a sparkly blue dress (not an AG dress) that really brought out the colour. I can see her as Alice, or maybe Elsa from Frozen. I think she’d look great in a royal blue sarafan and kokoshnik (if I can work out how to make a kokoshnik that will stay on a doll’s head).

#29 A
A rare find: a Truly Me doll correctly identified in the eBay listing. This was the first medium skin tone doll I bought in the Classic mould. I’d prefer her with darker hair, but she doesn’t look at all bad.

#29 B
I didn’t seek another #29 but she came as one of a pair with Marie-Grace 4 and was very cheap. She was also wearing the 2014 Happy Holidays dress which I’ll sell later on.

#38
Unfortunately this doll’s previous owner took scissors to her fringe, but I hope that I can get around that by giving her tight curls and allocating her to the late 19th century (or possibly the 1940s). If not, she can be either medieval with a wimple and coif, or a 1970s girl with a bandanna … or I could just get another wig for her.

#41?
I’m not entirely sure of this doll’s identity as her wig has been replaced (or at least re-glued), but she has dark green spiral/pinwheel eyes so #41 is the most likely. If I can squish her waist a little I think she’ll make a good Scarlett O’Hara.

#42
The second doll I bought new, this time through eBay, because it was very cheap (for a new doll) and I like the combination of Classic mould, medium skin and dark brown eyes and hair. I suspect she’s ex-benefit but I haven’t taken her out of the box to check yet. I’m tempted to try her out with Hawaiian/Polynesian outfits, or maybe northern Indian or South American.

#44
Another local find (NSW) and mis-identified as #43 in the listing (seriously? They are totally different) but I think that worked to my advantage. Her hair looked good in the photographs, with all her ringlets intact, but when I got her I found that the hair was matted at the roots and it took a fair bit of patience and a lot of VDFC to detangle it (but hey, that’s what TV is for, right?). Like #26 she has a serious gap in her wig at the front which is extremely disappointing — I don’t care what hairstyle is allocated to the doll, it’s very poor practice not to have a complete ring of hair around the edge. She also has what I suspect is baking soda residue in the ears and mouth, so there will be a skin cleanup.

#49
Although she is a medium-skin tone doll, the blue eyes made me think of Elizabeth Taylor, who was very tanned most of her life, as was the fashion in the 1950s-70s. I’ve actually purchased a pair of dark blue / indigo eyes for her to enhance the resemblance. While Taylor portrayed many historical roles, the costume designers in the 50s and 60s weren’t nearly as thorough as they are today and her film costumes are a very bad mix of period and contemporary elements (take Cleopatra, for example, where her dresses have typical 1960s “point and shoot” brassiere supports). I may well give her some historical outfits but I’ll try to be a little more period-appropriate within the limits of doll anatomy.

Dolls I would still like to get:

#69 – the dark hair with a centre parting would make her a good period-dress companion to Caroline and Felicity. (I may resort to re-wigging #23 or #38 but I’d rather have a #69.)

Courtney – if I ever buy her it will only be for completing the set of historical characters, as I don’t really find her attractive or interesting — I lived through the 80s and have no desire to repeat the experience even vicariously. I do like the mini-Molly though, she’s very cute.

Future posts:

I’m going to try and justify the money I spent by doing a series of comparison posts among the 70 AG dolls in my possession: moulds (including old and new Classic); skin tones; wigs; and body tags.

I wasn’t going to get an American Girl doll when I initially planned this venture as the cheapest I could find new was $225 (nearer $300 with shipping and import duties) and the ones I really liked were around $500, but then I started browsing eBay and found a thriving second-hand market. American Girl is is pretty much the standard reference for 18″ dolls now, so I did need one. One. The other 70 … not so much. I didn’t realise it at the time but it was the first step into a kind of insanity. I guess I should count myself lucky that I prefer to buy used rather than new, not just for the price but because it satisfies my hunting instinct more and also gives me the opportunity to care for dolls who might otherwise be thrown away.

I’m an archivist and completist at heart — I like having complete sets of books or discs and it turns out that AG dolls are no exception. There are 46 named dolls (49 if you count the re-releases separately) and 88 numbered dolls, making a total of 134 dolls. No, I don’t have all of them and I’m unlikely ever to get them all, but I do have at least one of each mould (except for the males), and I’m trying to have one in each skin tone too.

I should also note that since I’m in Australia I don’t have the option of sending dolls to the AG doll hospital for replacement limbs. This means that I have to be very selective in what I choose to bid on — I can’t replace chewed fingers or badly marked vinyl or torn bodies. I can get wigs and eyes, but they are expensive (around $40-60 per pair for eyes and $50-80 per wig, with shipping) so not something I can do for every doll. Still, even within those limitations I can have a lot of fun with restoration.

Today’s post will discuss my purchases in moulds other than the Classic.

Notes:
1. Unless otherwise stated, all the dolls were purchased used from eBay.
2. VDFC = very dilute fabric conditioner, my improvised braid spray (approximately 1% solution in tap water — our water here is very good, with a low mineral content).
3. Although (almost) all the photos were taken in the same location, they were taken over the span of a year in numerous sessions and the lighting varied quite a bit (even though I tried to standardise it as much as possible), so some duplicated dolls appear to have different skin tones but it’s just an artifact. I’ll do another post later on when I compare dolls directly with each other.

Addy mould

Addy
My Addy is a Pleasant Company doll, presumably from the 1990s (she has a brown body but no body tag). She’s very chubby — the largest of all my AG dolls, in fact. Her skin was a bit grubby but cleaned up easily, but the hair was extremely dry — so dry, in fact, that even gently combing the ends was causing bits to break off. Water spray didn’t help at all, but a VDFC treatment made a huge difference. I repeated it a week later and the condition of the hair was significantly better, with no breakages. The wig cap itself is not great (the mesh has stretched) but all in all she’s in very good condition for a 30-year old doll.

#58?
I was idly browsing several months after my previous doll purchase (always a mistake) and saw this poor girl being offered for 35 USD. Her face was covered in glitter and glue, her wig was in poor condition, her hands and feet had nail polish, and her left arm and body were badly stained. However, there were no apparent gouges, all her fingers and toes were intact and there were no tears in the body so I wanted to see if I could restore her. I put in my bid and went to bed, and found out the next morning that I had won the auction. In person the vinyl isn’t as bad as I thought but the cloth body is pretty bad so I’ll have to try and bleach it and/or dye it (and, to be honest, if that’s a success I’m tempted to re-dye all the very dark models because the torsos are disconcertingly light in comparison with the vinyl). Her wig is sown in rows across the top from front to back rather than the concentric circles on most wigs, so I think she might be a #58 (I haven’t seen any of that model up close so I can’t compare them). Regardless of her identity, I’m looking forward to making her beautiful again.

#26
I was a bit reluctant to get this one, as I wasn’t sold on the combination of the Addy mould and medium skin, but she’s actually quite pretty. Her wig is odd — it doesn’t look as if it’s been replaced, but there are spots at the front where the fabric around the wig edge is very visible. If the hair itself were in poor condition I’d be tempted to replace the wig, but it’s shiny and not too dry, so instead I applied permanent ink pens to the fabric areas to make them less visible, and if I pull the front section of hair down a little it doesn’t show at all. It’s very disappointing to see bald patches at the hairline in a quality doll brand though. [NB As I bought more dolls I discovered that this is a common defect. Not good at all.]

Asian Mould

#04
This doll was on the expensive side but there aren’t many of her on eBay and she came in her original box (American Girl Today) with several complete outfits. She has a slightly more golden tone than Ivy, and the short midface is very cute.

Jess mould

Ivy
This was an amazing find on eBay late one night — USD 70 for the doll, which is a bit more than I like to pay, but she’s not a common doll and she also came with the Chinese New Year outfit, which can sell for more than that on its own. Added to that, the postage quoted was the lowest I’ve ever seen. I hit that “Buy It Now” button so fast I surprised myself. By sheer coincidence, she arrived on Chinese New Year day (7 February 2020). She has the extended eye sockets and her wig appears to be original (if slightly trimmed). Her body tag has been cut off but there is no different in skin tone between head and limbs so I’m pretty sure she’s all Ivy.

Kanani 1
I’m not at all fond of the medium skin / hazel eyes combination but I’m sure I’ll be able to work with it. She’s lost a couple of inches of her hair but it’s still below her hips and she’s otherwise in good condition. If I find I really can’t live with the eyes I’ll replace them.

Kanani 2
I bought this doll from Norway, of all places. She’s had a rough life — there was a small hole in the front of the body, which I darned, and her hair has been cut short. The wig issue is actually a bonus for me, though, because I don’t feel at all bad about modifying her. She’s going to get brown eyes and a dark brown wig to make her look more Polynesian — I’ve seen a couple of stunning custom Kananis with that combination.

Kanani 3
This doll is in beautiful condition and came with her meet dress plus the faux kukui nut necklace and flower hair clip. On stripping her down for photography and measurements, however, I found that her body has a medium length tag saying Made in China but without the date, while the other two have long tags that say © 2011, so I think she’s a frankendoll. I’m not sure where the body came from but the skin tone matches exactly, so for me it’s no big deal.

#30
She is an ex-benefit sale doll (X on the bottom) but is in good condition, and I wanted a light-skinned Jess mould doll. It’s impossible to tell the difference between Jess and #30 if you don’t have the original box unless the #30 was from a batch made in or after 2011 when the long tags were implemented. Mine only has a short tag so was a pre-2011 make.

#40
Having already bought #30 I wasn’t intending to get another Jess mould doll, but this one was in like-new condition and came with a lot of AG outfits that I figured would offset the cost when I sell them. She’s from 2017 and has permapanties but honestly they don’t bother me much and they won’t show under clothing.

Josefina mould

Blaire
Strictly speaking, I don’t have this doll — I bought her new for my cousin Suzy to use as a model for knitted clothes, but since we’re all going to live together in a few years I guess she counts as part of the line-up. Her long hair makes her very adaptable to period costumes so I can see her as an older Anne Shirley or Merida or a young Queen Bess. I apologise for the quality of the photo — I didn’t want to open the box before sending it up to Suzy, and it had to be at an angle to avoid flash reflection.

Elizabeth 1
My first Josefina mould doll. I bought this doll as one of a pair with Felicity 1. They both came in hospital boxes but I’m not sure what was replaced — the head is definitely not new (although her hair is in beautiful condition). She had her meet dress but no other clothing or accessories. She is one of the prettiest of the Josefina mould dolls, and I’m keen to make up some 18th / 19th century outfits for her.

Elizabeth 2
I was actually bidding on Maryellen 1 and saw that this doll was from the same seller. She was in good condition but no one had bid on her at all. Since the auction ended early in the morning (my time) I put in a bid and then went to bed. I was surprised to wake up and see that I had won both auctions. She’s in excellent condition apart from a couple of tiny marks on the body. At this stage I’m not sure if I’ll keep her or sell her, but I’m certainly going to dress her.

Josefina 1
This doll was a great find — not only did she come in her box with three sets of clothes that look brand new, but her wig has been replaced with a Beautifully Custom wig that reaches to her ankles (the weight of it also makes her extremely difficult to pose). I’d prefer it if the wig were darker, to be honest, so I may change it later on.

Josefina 2
This doll came in an early AG hospital gown and she is definitely in need of some TLC. Her earrings are corroded so they’ll need a bit of Brasso to clean up. Her skin is very grubby and when I started cleaning her it seemed like the whole top layer was sloughing. I suspect that someone used a cleaning agent or spray seal that has reacted with the vinyl. Given that cleaning her up properly means taking off all her face paint (and probably removing her eyes too) she’s at the back of the queue for now.

Julie
I was a teenager in the 1970s so I well remember the terrible, terrible fashion choices people made — hot pants, flairs, crochet dresses and giant floppy hats. On the other hand I loved the Gunne Sax style dresses and actually made a couple for myself (all lace and flowers and ribbon) so adapting those patterns for a doll will be great fun. Julie’s long straight hair is perfect for this era but can easily fit into any other. To be honest, I’m a little ambivalent about the brown eyes with flaxen hair because most people with flaxen hair have blue or grey eyes. After much searching I have found a pair of grey eyes that aren’t too light so I may try them out in her. Note to anyone buying eyes from etsy or eBay: eyes that look great in isolation can look really weird when inserted into a doll’s face. Always check to see if there are photos of the eyes in situ rather than in a box or on a flat surface.

Lea
I’m not sure why AG has such a preference for matching medium skin tones with hazel eyes but at least it doesn’t look as bad in Lea as it does in Kanani (and #79). This doll wasn’t identified in the listing and the photos weren’t great, but I was reasonably sure she was a Lea and she was very cheap in comparison with the named Lea listings. Hair was a bit wild but has been tamed with VDFC.

Marisol
Sold as “brunette, brown eyes”. Lovely colouring and a very pretty face (and her eyes are brown, yay!). I’d like to make matching or coordinating outfits for her and Lea as they are almost mirror twins.

McKenna
For some reason I don’t feel much of a connection to this doll — I’m not sure why. She’s in reasonable condition and her hair isn’t too dry. I may sell her or I may customise her. On the other hand, the fact that her hair is pulled back at the forehead means I could probably do an eighteenth century or Edwardian hairstyle quite easily. We’ll see how she manages in period clothes and then make a decision.

Nellie
This was a “Buy It Now” purchase where I could have saved maybe $20 by bidding on an auction, but the two auctions that looked promising ended early in the morning (my time) and had a couple of bids already. Nellie was my third-last eBay purchase of early 2020 and I just wanted to be done with getting all the historical characters so that my completist urge was satisfied and I could log out of eBay permanently (or at least until my credit card recovered). Her hair is fairly short, so limited in style, but I can definitely dress her in Edwardian children’s style and later 20th century adult styles. I may take a solvent swab to her freckles (I have freckles myself and I’ve never liked them) but that’s not a decision to be made in a hurry.

Rebecca
A surprise find on eBay, not identified in the listing (“AG doll, curly hair”). The lighting in the photos was a little odd, and it took me a while to work out that she is a Rebecca. Her hair is still curly but was rather dry, so VDFC to the rescue again.

#80
Bought new directly from American Girl (along with a Maryellen for my cousin Jo) — she cost around AUD 260 with shipping and import duty. This is the only dark-skinned Josefina mould doll — she looks Indian or Sri Lankan to me so I’d love to make her a sari or shalwar kameez in bright silks. I know that you can buy used / damaged saris for fairly low prices on eBay and etsy, so I can either recycle them or use paints and pencils to make border patterns on plain silk. Sorry about the photo — I don’t actually have this doll in my possession yet and the photo was sent to me by Suzy.

Joss mould

Joss
Bought new via Amazon. I love the new mould — she seems to include the best aspects of the Josefina, Marie-Grace and Classic moulds. Although she’s a “modern” doll I’m sure that I can find a period dress or two for her, and I’m tempted to try sourcing or making an ear trumpet to replace the hearing aid. As a new doll she has perfect skin and hair, of course, so no maintenance required.

Kaya mould

Kaya 1
This one was a bit dirty but otherwise in reasonable condition. Her hair has been trimmed but still reaches to her hips and wasn’t too dry. After treating it I bound it up in two Leia-style buns to try and entice some curl back into it.

Kaya 2
This one has had a drastic hair cut and is going to get a wig replacement. As well as Native American costumes, I’d like to try making her some of the very colourful outfits prevalent in South America.

Marie-Grace mould

Ah, Marie-Grace. I’m not sure why, but this is by far my favourite doll. I love her little heart-shaped face, her delicate features and her unusually coloured eyes. Even the fact that her hair is plain brown instead of blonde or dark brown endears her more to me. The only thing I don’t like is her meet dress — it looks all right in photographs but it feels like it’s made out of umbrella nylon. I guess it could be for ease of cleaning, but when so many other AG dolls get cotton or satin dresses it seems like a slap in the face.

Marie-Grace 1
The very first American Girl doll I bought, from eBay back in September 2019. She was USD 85, but the exchange rate, shipping and import duties brought it up to AUD 202. Her hair is still in the original style, with ribbons, and she had her meet outfit and accessories (no boxes) so the price was good for what I got. I was originally going to pull her waist in with darts so that she can wear the very tight-waisted Victorian styles, but I think I’ll do that with MG2 instead.

Marie-Grace 2
She cost less than MG1 but a little more than I usually spend on used dolls, but although she’s lost her plaits and pin curls she’s in good condition. She arrived in the Grecian Princess outfit (sans sandals) which I would like a lot better if it was in cotton or linen and not cheap nylon. Given that her hair has lost its original style I think this will be the doll that gets the waist modification.

Marie-Grace 3
I bought this one from an Australian seller. She has been customised as Daenerys Targaryen with Caroline’s eyes and wig, and her face has been painted. The photograph shows that the blusher and lip colour are from different sides of the red spectrum (it’s less obvious in real life) so she needs a bit of revision. I’ll also re-do the eyebrows as they are too dark — I know Daenerys has dark eyebrows but I don’t like them with the flaxen hair.

Marie-Grace 4
I wasn’t going to buy another used MG doll, but she was listed with a #29 as “Pair of AG dolls” and was very cheap. She had no original clothes with her, but her hair is in great condition with ribbons, and she’s very clean.

Marie-Grace 5
I finally caved and bought a new doll with box and accessories. Expensive, but so, so worth it. This one is going to be kept in the box and not played with, just looked at fondly and maybe petted a little.

Marie-Grace 6
A surprise local listing (Sydney), with several of Marie-Grace’s outfits and accessories. She cost a bit much, but at least most of the money went on the doll and not on shipping. For a “near-new” doll her joints are surprisingly loose, so I may end up re-stringing her. Otherwise she’s in great condition and will be cherished along with MG5.

Given that I feel enormously protective towards Marie-Grace dolls I may buy more if they appear to be in need of a good home … but not for a while.

Nanea Mould

Nanea
This was the first AG doll I bought new, through Amazon marketplace. With the exchange rate, postage and import duties it came to almost $250. I love her face, though I wish she had brown eyes rather than the hazel that AG puts in almost every mixed-race doll. I haven’t taken her out of the box yet but I want to make a holoku for her, and maybe some Thai or Malay costumes. I have no idea if she has the “defective” eyes that buyers complained about — they don’t look any different to me — but I’ll probably swap them out for brown eventually.

Sonali mould

Cecile
Bought new through eBay from someone in Sydney. Cecile was second-last doll I needed in order to have all the historical dolls (prior to Courtney). I didn’t particularly want a new one but used Ceciles are as rare as hen’s teeth, and knowing my impulse-buying tendencies I wanted to get her so that I could cut myself off from eBay. And oh, look, she has hazel eyes, who would have guessed. /s (Seriously, someone needs to remind AG that 80% of the world’s population has brown eyes; we blue/green/grey-eyed people are the mutants.)

Gabriela 1
Sold nude as “medium skin brunette”. Her hair has been cut short but still looks good — I’m going to even it up a bit and leave it short as it suits her. Her body tag is long and is ©2017 so she is almost certainly Gabriela and not a #46.

Gabriela 2
This one is definitely a Gabriela and came with her meet outfit. Her hair is in excellent condition and her skin is clean.

Melody
This doll was part of the final completist push early in 2020. I was actually contemplating getting her from the AG website, but I found an ex-benefit sale new doll for only USD 75, and even with the postage and import duties it was less than I would have had to pay AG. I’d like to make a couple of 1960s outfits for her, like the Mondrian dress and a a couple of those dance dresses with miles of tulle underneath.

Sonali
My very last AG purchase (for the time being, at least). She’s the only doll ever marketed as Indian, which is both surprising and disappointing considering that people from the subcontinent have migrated to every country and there are sizable populations in both the US and Canada (and Australia, of course). I’ve been after one for ages, but she had a short run (2009 only) and there aren’t many available, even used. The new ones are listed at USD 500 or upwards which is too much even for me. I tried to buy a used one from eBay a few months ago but received an entirely different item (I believe the mix-up occurred at the International Shipping Centre in Kentucky but as eBay refunded me I’m leaving that up to the seller to resolve). Then in December 2020 I was idly browsing and came across a lovely excellent condition used doll for only USD 190, which is much less than I paid for the first attempt, though still the most money I’ve paid for any AG doll. I was even happier to see that the exchange rate is better, too, so all in all it cost me AUD 70 less than the first attempt. I’m really looking forward to dressing her and #80 as sisters in colourful silk saris and shalwar kameez.

#46
Listed as “18” African American doll”. I thought she might be a Gabriela, but when I got her I found that her body tag is ©2014 so she has to be a #46. Her hair had been cut and was incredibly dirty; once washed it was still a little wavy but will need to be re-curled. NB she looks darker than Gabriela in the photo but that’s just an artefact, she’s actually the same colour.

#47
Listed as Addy. I’m not 100% sure this is a #47 as her wig has been replaced (or was applied very sloppily), but she has a different, slightly darker and slightly yellower skin tone than the #46/Gabriela dolls have. Given that her body tag is ©2017, the only other doll she could be with this skin tone is #67 and that’s not likely, so I’ll stick with #47. She is definitely not an Addy!

Dolls I would still like to get:

#50
Addy mould but with long smooth hair in a centre parting. This is a long shot, as she was only available 2009-12, but I’ll keep an eye out. She’d make a wonderful companion for Sonali and #80 in a sari, shalwar kameez or lehenga.

#86
Josefina mould, medium skin and magenta hair — what’s not to like? She’s so new I’d probably have to buy her from the AG website or from a reseller, both of which would be expensive, so definitely not in the near future. But one day, maybe …

Tomorrow I’ll talk about all my Classic mould dolls.

As several of my friends know, I’m planning to move to Tasmania in a few years (when I get my lump sum) and I’ll be living with two of my cousins who are about my age. One of the things we’ve discussed has been an occasional craft market stall. I sew (by hand and machine), Suzy knits and weaves, and Jo crochets and sews, so among us we have a good spread of skills. I’d like to make some dolls’ clothing to sell, but I can’t use the two dolls I’ve had since childhood as fitting models because one (Sandra) is too small and the other (Julie) is too big, and I’ll need to make clothes that fit today’s dolls. To that end, I started buying 18″ dolls to use as reference / fitting models. Originally I was only going to get a couple of cheap reference dolls but then insanity happened and I now have 90 (yes, ninety) — I wrote about this here. I originally meant to do these doll posts in late 2019, but I kept buying more dolls and so kept postponing the entries. I think I’ve pretty much stopped now, so it’s time to do the introductions (although I’ve already posted a couple of the dolls in dresses I’ve made over the last few months).

Notes
1. For overseas readers, Target Australia and Kmart Australia are NOT the same as the similarly named stores in North America. The Australian stores are both owned by Wesfarmers, which is Australia’s biggest company by revenue (they also own Bunnings and OfficeWorks).
2. VDFC = Very Dilute Fabric Conditioner (approximately a 1% solution) = my improvised braid spray.

A. Locally available dolls
(arranged in order of retail price, not including shipping)

1. “Positively Perfect” doll (Chloe) – available from Target Australia ($10 — a very low price, so I think she might have been on sale) or Wal-Mart in the US. For a ten-dollar doll she’s actually not bad — her hair is two different colours and came attached to a plastic strip to minimise tangling. The hair was extremely difficult to comb initially but I tried it with VDFC and that made it much better. Her eyes are painted. Her head seem disproportionately large, even for a doll, but I can disguise that by dressing her in bulky outfits.

2. “My Sweet Friend” doll (unnamed) – available from Target Australia ($22). She came in a ballerina outfit so I named her Galina, after Galina Ulanova, the Russian prima ballerina assoluta. Nordic and/or Russian outfits would suit her best.

3. “Design A Friend” doll (Lola) – available from Big W in Australia ($29 – 44) or Argos in the UK. Much thinner than the other cloth-torso dolls and her torso is a bit misaligned, giving her an apparent leg length discrepancy. In spite of that she does stand. Tons of hair … maybe a little too much as I had to put it into a couple of plaits to keep it under control (seriously, she has more hair on her tiny head than I’ve ever had on mine). Her head is also the largest, proportionately. She has painted eyes. She already has a small waist, and her torso is so squishy I think I can squeeze her into a Victorian silhouette without too much effort (obviously I wouldn’t be able to sell any clothes I fit to her after that, but that wouldn’t matter too much as long as the dresses look good).

4a. “Our Generation” doll (Valencia) — available from David Jones, Kmart and online in Australia ($35 – 60). I noted that DJ has some dolls that are not on the Australian OG website and vice versa. As with most OG dolls she appears to be quite startled, but I may be able to fix that by wiping and re-drawing the eyebrows. She has a lovely skintone.

4b. “Our Generation” Pearl — she’s a Hair Play doll that was available exclusively from David Jones in Australia for a time (she’s not even on the Australian OG website). I chose her for her hair colour and length as I wanted to try dressing it in eighteenth century styles. Unfortunately, when I ordered her I forgot something — she has a button on her back to alter the length of the three plaits. It’s a big button and it means I can’t put a corset on her. As it is, I’m going to have to file down the edges of the button to avoid a 90 degree bump. At least I can make sacque dresses for her (even if massive hair wasn’t quite contemporaneous) and some of the late Regency styles had a bit of a bustle along with the high waist so they’ll be good candidates, too. It’s almost impossible to get her to stand unsupported with the hair up, because of the weight distribution, so I’m going to have to get a stand for her.

5. “Soy Tu” doll by Paola Reina (Emily) – available from speciality toyshops ($129). I was reluctant to get this one originally but decided she was cute enough to warrant the price, especially in comparison with the Götz dolls on the next shelf. I was not expecting the intense vanilla smell, though, and it took two vodka rubdowns and a few nights on the balcony (prior to the bushfires) before the smell dissipated to a tolerable level. When I measured her I found that she is smaller and thinner than the other dolls (height 42 cm, waist 20 cm) so she can’t be used as a reference doll. Still, she’ll make a good sister for Sandra, my smaller childhood doll.

6. “Florrie” doll (No 5) formerly available online or through the Florrie store in Melbourne ($150). The best packaging of all by far, but I’m not sure that’s a good thing — I’d rather the money went into the doll than the boxes. I’m still working out a name for her — she looks like an Emily to me but that’s a name already used by several doll companies (and also by Sarah Crewe in A Little Princess). My grandmother was called Florence Emily so I’ll probably stick to calling her Florrie (or maybe Flossie), which isn’t really fair to her but at least it avoids confusion. Unfortunately the Florrie business closed permanently around March 2020 so these dolls are no longer available.

7a. “Australian Girl” doll (Matilda), available online or from a few specialist shops here. ($160) I was a bit surprised to see how dull her skintone is in comparison with the others. She has lovely subtle touches of rose on her face, neck, knees and feet, but overall she appears rather grey. Then I actually checked against my own skintone (I’m of Scottish heritage so very pale for an Australian) and found that in fact it’s quite close to real skin colour while all the other dolls are too pinky-orange. She is also larger than the others — 50 cm (20″) but I can probably work around that. I tried brushing her hair but immediately realised why brushes and curls are not a good combination. It took several hours to restore the finger curls. (In my defence, I have extremely fine straight hair and it’s been 40 years since I had a perm. One forgets.) Unfortunately she has some staining on her arms and legs from the doll carrier she arrived in — I undressed her for photos and measurements but didn’t re-dress her before putting her back in the carrier. I’ll have to see if metho or acetone can remove the stains.

7b. “Australian Girl” doll Bronte – she was fairly cheap on ebay (around $50 I think) because her hair had been hacked off but I was able to get my hairdresser to trim it so that it looks a little more chic. She’s destined for the Aussie Heros charity auction next year after I make an army uniform for her.

Around the same time as I bought Matilda I made the decision to buy a couple of dolls that technically aren’t sold in Australia but are fairly popular in doll blog/vlog land and can be obtained online easily (if not cheaply). I also wanted a greater ethnic variety. Then I found others that I liked and that triggered my archivist/completist gene and I ended up with … many. The following are in order of purchase, more or less. (If I’d known what was going to happen I might have run away screaming.)

Imported dolls

9a. “Journey Girl” doll (Kyla) — I bought her new through Amazon for $106 ($50 for the doll, the rest was shipping and import duties). She has a sweet face that reminds me a little of the Duchess of Sussex and a vinyl upper body that will suit lower necklines. She’s a little thinner than most of the 18″ dolls so a tightly fitted dress won’t be transferrable. Saris, on the other hand, would be great.

9b. “Journey Girl” doll (Kelsey). I had already bought Kyla but she was local (Victoria) and very cheap ($52), and she has lovely colouring.

10. “Kindred Hearts” doll (Paige) I bought new through Amazon ($93 including shipping, the doll was about $50) — this is a less popular brand, but she has Asian features and as we have a lot of people from that region here I wanted some representation (and the excuse to make a qipao/cheongsam). Further research leads me to believe that hanfu, hanbok, kimono, áo dài and other regional outfits will be made as well.

11. “Madame Alexander” doll – another ebay purchase ($86). I’m not sure of the line but after consulting Dollation I think the most likely is the original “My Life As”, though “Favorite Friends/Play” is another possibility — unfortunately none of her four labels has a date on it. She has very striking colouring and appears a little “older” than the other dolls. Her neck is permanently tilted which I wasn’t aware of before she arrived but apart from that I like her. Her hair, however, was very wild and extremely dry when I got her and didn’t repond much to VDFC, so after washing it I ended up using the hair straightener on her. Interestingly, her hair is much more heat-resistant than American Girl hair, and it took 3-4 slow runs on each strand to get it smooth. Her colouring cries out for the exaggerated fashion of the 1950s / early 1960s, or possibly the “power dressing” outfits of the 1980s.

12. “Carpatina” doll (Rowena) bought used through ebay, the cost ended up around $140. I wasn’t aware of this brand until I bought a couple of doll patterns from Pixie Faire and saw them (Carpatina does good patterns, by the way, and also doll-scale fabric). Although she is technically an 18″ doll she is much thinner than all the others. She has a vaguely medieval look about her face and she was dressed in a typical robe of that era, so I suspect she may be named for the Saxon noblewoman in Sir Walter Scott’s novel Ivanhoe. Kirtles and surcotes and houppelands are in her future, and since her hair is very long and very red I’ll give the costumes from Brave a try. The hair was very dry and tangled at the ends, and unfortunately the glue holding her wig on has dried up completely so the whole wig came off as I was combing it out. I’ll have to clean up the head and research the best wig-fixing glue for vinyl dolls.

13. “Adora Amazing Girl” doll (Jada) bought new via Amazon ($150). She is described as African American but I think she could be South Indian or Australian Aboriginal just as easily. Beautiful cheekbones and gorgeous deep colouring. She’s really crying out for rich golds and grassy greens.

14a. Citytoys “My Life As” doll (Sleepover host, no name) bought new through Amazon (USD30). I love her smile. Although technically a cheap doll she’s not bad, and her hair is lovely. I think she’d suit 1970s fashions — all flowing lines and glowing golden tones.

14b. Citytoys “My Life As” (Schoolgirl, no name). This was listed as “Citytoys” on ebay and unfortunately I wasn’t aware that Citytoys make the current MLA dolls until I unwrapped her and saw how much she resembled the Sleepover doll. Her hair actually frightens me — it’s very woolly and the ends are dry, but a tentative stab at combing it out was abandoned after only one strand. I’m honestly not sure if her hair can be combed out. A liberal spray of 1% fabric conditioner solution had negligible effect on the dryness so the only treatment option for her is a Downy Dunk unless I want to remove the curls completely (which I don’t). If anyone has any experience in dealing with this sort of doll hair I would be most grateful for advice.

15. “Worldwide Selection” doll (Blonde, no name) bought new through Amazon (USD 70). Facially she resembles Our Generation but her expression is harder and less startled (in spite of the white showing at the bottom of her eyes). In fact, I’m contemplating taking off the blond wig and getting a boy wig for her, as I have no male dolls. If not, the fringe will limit her to 20th century or child styles.

16. “Springfield” doll (Maria) bought new through Amazon (USD 26). Her face isn’t quite as pleasing as some of the other dolls, but she isn’t hideous either. I’m still not sure which era will suit her best.

17. “Sophia’s” doll (Brooklyn) bought new through Amazon (USD 42). She has a full vinyl body which is unusual these days. She’s very pretty, though, and bright colours will bring out that lovely blush. She looks very thin in comparison with the soft-body dolls, but her torso measurements are very close to Florrie and Journey Girls.

18. “Faithful Friends” (Beth). This was a surprise finding on ebay ($132). The Heidi Ott dolls are mostly 1:12 miniatures but at one stage they brought out a line of 18″ dolls and Beth was one of them. Although she resembles the Worldwide Selection doll (blonde fringe and plaits) I decided to get her anyway. Unfortunately her body is very unusual in its shape and size, so anything I make for her wouldn’t fit or look good on any other doll. I’ve re-dressed her and put her back in her box, and I may sell her next year. I could always make her into a boy (she’s 47cm tall and very wide in the shoulders) but it seems a shame to do that to a doll that’s been preserved in a like-new condition for so many years.

19. Last and, in one sense only, least – Nahji from the Heart for Hearts doll range. This is a complete indulgence as she is very small (14″ / 35 cm) and can’t be used as a model, but she was so pretty I couldn’t help myself. One of her earrings was broken but that’s no big deal. She is destined for saris and shalwaar kameez in as many bright colours as I can find.

There are three more doll brands I’ve considered but won’t buy — one available locally and two online:

Götz Precious Day doll — I saw these in person when I bought the Paola Reina doll but decided to pass. I’m not keen on the face mould and they looked very small — even slimmer than the Soy Tu though they are advertised as 18″/45 cm. They are $120 upward in stores.

Sew Nice — they do great doll clothing, but I don’t like the face on their dolls. Price is $80 each or $120 for two, plus shipping which is not listed on the website (but they are in Bendigo, Victoria so it wouldn’t be much for me).

Dollmaker — Although I like the concept (being able to choose face mould, skin tone, wig style and hair and eye colour independently) I’m not keen on any of the moulds, so that’s a no for now … although, now I’ve had another look at them I think Punkin or Carly would make a decent boy doll, so maybe I’ll reconsider in the future. Starting price is USD 110, plus shipping.

Although all these dolls are sold as 18″ dolls, there is quite a bit of variation in their body shape as you can see in the photos. Australian Girl and Our Generation are fairly chunky, whereas Journey Girl and Design A Friend are slender, and Carpatina is positively skinny. I’ll do a separate post with a formal comparison to illustrate the variations among them.

If you’ve noticed one very significant brand omission, that’s because this post is already too long. Tomorrow and the next day I’ll talk about my American Girl dolls.